Pages

Wednesday, June 20, 2012

How long did the police spend investigating Trayvon Martin?



Did the Trayvon Martin investigation run its course too quickly?  This seems to be one of the biggest issues that protestors return to again and again, the fact that it only took seven hours and 50 minutes for Sanford police and the state attorney to decide to let George Zimmerman to go home, not charging him with the shooting death of Trayvon Martin.


 


According to MSNBC, nearby Lake Mary is a similar town with the same number of detectives (five).  Two years ago a shooting happened in Lake Mary and although eventually no charges were filed that city’s homicide unit called in the county sheriff’s department with its fully staffed crime lab to assist.  That investigation lasted for 16 days. 


 


Was seven hours too quick of an investigation?  Kendall Kendall Coffey, former United States Attorney thinks so.  “When a man with a gun kills someone who is unarmed, certainly should take a lot more than seven hours to reach the bottom line as to whether there's a crime,” he explains.


                                                                                                                                    


The special prosecutor examining the case will be the one to determine the truth of the matter, and is expected to report to the grand jury soon.


Tuesday, June 19, 2012

It doesn't take much to get away with murder

Kendall Coffey bio


There a lot of different issues at play in the Trayvon Martin case.  There are the pictures of George Zimmerman’s injuries.  There’s the fact that he refused to stay in his car after the police dispatcher instructed him to.  There’s the mere seven hours that the police held him.  There’s Martin’s innocence and complete right to be exactly where he was.  There’s the confusion over who was calling for help in the 911 call. 

 


But the only issue that matters, according to Kendall Coffey, is who threw the first punch. 


 


This is because the case comes down to a strange Florida law called Stand Your Ground which allows someone to meet force with force if they aren’t engaging in unlawful activity and are attacked in someplace where they have the right to be. 


 


As Kendall Coffey explains, if Martin threw the first punch, no matter if he was scared of Zimmerman, Zimmerman would have had every right to shoot him.  If Zimmerman threw the first punch then he would have been taking part in unlawful activity and could not seek protection under the SYG statute.


 


With such a strange law, apparently all it takes in Florida to get away with murder is getting the other guy to attack you first.


 

Monday, June 18, 2012

Does all the evidence bolster Zimmerman's claim of self defense?


Kendall coffey bio


A great deal of evidence has been released in the Trayvon Martin case.  Several weeks ago the case seemed very different, before the stories, the pictures of the injuries, the witnesses accounts, all of which seems to bolster Zimmerman’s claims of self defense.  But does it?


 


Kendall Coffey was asked that very question on MSNBC.  Author of Spinning the Law, he’s an expert at trying cases in the court of public opinion.  But Coffey doesn’t think that the public reaction will change much, although it could affect the case all the same.


 


“This does more good for Zimmerman than it does for the prosecution because it tells us there are very important unanswered questions,” he explains.  “Enough unanswered questions mean unproven facts and... those are the tools of a defense lawyer trying to establish a reasonable doubt.”

Thursday, May 31, 2012

Case could affect future of foreclosures


Kendall Coffey

Even though the lawsuit is already settled, Roman Pino v. Bank of New York Mellon could affect how foreclosures are filed across the entire United States. 

Right now, banks aren’t precisely as careful about the foreclosures they file because they don’t have to be.  If something ever goes wrong, say- if they filed the foreclosure with fraudulent documents- all they have to do is dismiss the mortgage and re-file correctly. 

In case you thought that fraudulent documents reference was an excessive one, the very lawsuit at hand deals with that issue.  Roman Pino’s mortgage assignment, the legal document that binds a loan to a lender, had been signed by a low-wage worker hired to simply sign the document without the due diligence of checking the document for accuracy- as is usually required.

Pino owns his house now, as the case was settled out of court, but the Florida Supreme Court is still hearing the case.  Many foreclosures in Florida have had similar fraudulent paperwork, and the voluntary dismissal strategy might be at fault.   Essentially, there is little incentive not to lie. 

As Amanda Lundergan, an associate with the law firm that represented Pino, explained, “It sets up a system where every litigant is condoned and encouraged to lie, cheat and steal, knowing that if they are caught, they can simply voluntarily dismiss and absolve themselves from that fraud."

There could be wide backlash if the court rules against voluntary dismissal.  There were more than 104,000 cases voluntarily dismissed from Florida’s courts last year.  In fact, if the court rules against the banks, "a broad universe of mortgages could be rendered unenforceable," said former U.S. Attorney Kendall Coffey, author of the book, "Foreclosures in Florida."

Will Zimmerman have to take the stand at his trial?

Read more at Kendall Coffey Celebrity Cases

 In the current climate it might make more sense if he didn’t.  After all, the public is following every bit of information with bated breath, see-sawing from one opinion to another, and him taking the stand will only feed the rumor mill- which is something that his attorney’s office seems determined to avoid.

“The O'Mara Law group stresses that while the George Zimmerman case will be explored deeply in the media and by the public, the only proper place to determine the guilt or innocence of George Zimmerman is in court,” a posting on Zimmerman’s legal defense website posted recently.  “And indeed only the jury will have all the evidence required to make such a determination.

But one of the prosecutors, Bernie De La Rionda, has hinted that Zimmerman’s story to the police varied, bringing up the possibility that he gave false testimony. And according to Miami attorney Kendall Coffey, this means that Zimmerman might very well have to take the stand.

“The most critical information in the trial could be his believability," Coffey says. "This defendant is asserting self-defense and it would be very difficult to assert self-defense without taking the stand to explain how it happened. All the more difficult if the police are holding in their hands contradictory accounts."

Tuesday, May 29, 2012

Mudslinging and attack ads in the sunshine state

Kendall Coffey

We all know about attack ads. In fact, in an election cycle a certain amount of misleading mudslinging is expected.  But in Florida, at least, some candidates are fighting back.

Back when the recent health care bill was passed Republicans saw a chance to label the Democrats as anti-Medicare.  How?  Well, while the bill actually increases Medicare spending from $560 billion this year to $1.04 trillion in ten years, the health care bill does assume that during that time the program will result in savings of about $500 billion- mostly through increased efficiency.

But rather than explaining all of this, Republicans are just labeling the savings as cuts and telling the public that the Democrats are cutting Medicare by $500 billion.  And they’re using those numbers in a recent set of attack ads.

Not everyone is content to simply get angry at the misinformation, however.  Senator Bill Nelson, Democrat, has embarked upon a quest to get those ads off the air.  In a letter written by his attorney, former U.S. Attorney Kendall Coffey, he explains that these letters are blatantly untrue.

And stations have “a duty to protect the public from the spread of false information and deliberate deception,” writes Coffey.

Not that such letters will have made much a difference so far.  Several stations have rejected the letter from Coffey and will continue showing the messages.  But it’s nice to have someone who is willing to fight back.


Thursday, May 3, 2012

Zimmerman's former attorneys' actions baffling


The Atlantic Wire has an interesting piece analyzing the actions of George Zimmerman's former attorneys, an piece that comes to the conclusion that perhaps they were the ones that went rogue, not their client.  Some of the reasons include:

They gave a press conference.  Dropping a client isn't unusual, lawyers do it every day.  But quitting via press conference is highly unusual.
Kendall Coffey, a former U.S. Attorney in Miami and author of Spinning the Law, said Uhrig and Sonner's decision to hold a news conference was baffling. "The lawyers have every right to withdraw, but it's highly unusual," he said. "In the court of public opinion, the press conference was not helpful for George Zimmerman."
They discussed George Zimmerman's mental state: Describing Zimmerman as "emotionally crippled" and posssibly suffering from PTSD is not only in bad taste, it's unethical.
"It's unbelievable that you would get on television and talk about your client's mental state," Jose Baez, a criminal defense attorney told CNN last night. "What you have here, as an attorney, you have an ethical obligation to not only not post attorney-client communication but attorney-client confidence. Things you learn in the process of representing a client are considered confidential so any conversations they have are completely protected and the holder of this privilege is George Zimmerman ... It's reprehensible."
Other concerns include the fact that they only waited three days after not hearing from Zimmerman before having a press conference and that, through explaining this, they implied that Zimmerman might be a flight risk, therefore damaging his reputation.